Comparing Scrut and Thoropass

---

About Scrut

Scrut is a compliance platform that handles multiple frameworks like SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, PCI DSS, and GDPR through automated evidence collection and continuous control monitoring. The platform includes risk and vendor management features, policy templates, and lets auditors work directly inside the system to collaborate on audit projects. It connects to cloud services, identity management, HR systems, and other business tools, though it has fewer integrations than some competitors. Pricing appears to be quote-based and potentially expensive for smaller companies.

About Thoropass

Thoropass combines compliance automation software with an audit team in one platform. The system gathers evidence automatically from integrations with cloud services and business tools, then uses AI to review that evidence while auditors work directly within the platform. It handles multiple compliance frameworks like SOC 2, ISO 27001, and HIPAA through a single interface, with pre-built policy templates and control mappings. Users get access to both the software and their assigned auditors from the start, rather than having to find separate auditors after using a compliance tool.

What do users say?

We've used AI to analyze a number of reviews from third-party sites like G2, Reddit, and Capterra, and here's what the AI found:

Based on reviews, Scrut provides streamlined compliance management with automated evidence collection and a clean dashboard that offers clear visibility of compliance requirements across frameworks like SOC2, ISO27001, and GDPR. Users consistently praise the exceptional customer support and responsive team guidance that helps organizations navigate the compliance process step-by-step, with many noting the platform's cost-effectiveness compared to competitors. However, some users report performance issues including slow loading times, bugs with evidence uploading, and note that the platform can feel overwhelming for new users without sufficient training.

Based on reviews, Thoropass is praised for its user-friendly platform that simplifies complex compliance processes like SOC 2 and ISO 27001, with users highlighting its intuitive interface, clear dashboards, task-oriented roadmap, and strong customer support that helps remove ambiguity around compliance requirements. Users consistently mention that the platform saves time through automation capabilities and easy integrations with existing systems, making traditionally painful audit processes more manageable. Some users note that the UI can feel cluttered at scale and mention limited customization options, though these concerns appear to be outweighed by the platform's overall effectiveness in streamlining compliance work.

Comparison

Scrut

Based on reviews, Scrut provides strong GRC depth with guided onboarding through its Setup Wizard, helping organizations navigate multi-framework compliance requirements. The platform enables auditor collaboration directly within the system, reducing email back-and-forth during audit processes.

Thoropass

Based on reviews, Thoropass offers an all-in-one experience combining compliance automation with built-in audit execution, eliminating the need to manage separate platforms and auditors. The platform provides 200+ robust integrations and strong G2 momentum, though pricing varies by framework and lacks transparency.

Feature Comparison

Feature	Scrut	Thoropass
Built-in Auditors	N	Y
Multi-framework Support	Y	Y
Automated Evidence Collection	Y	Y
Risk Management	Y	Y
Vendor Management	Y	N
Trust Center	Y	Y
Penetration Testing	N	Y
PCI ASV Scanning	N	Y
AI Evidence Review	N	Y
100+ Integrations	N	Y

Built-in Auditors

Scrut offers auditor collaboration through its Audit Center, allowing external auditors to work within the platform but requires organizations to source their own auditing firm. The platform facilitates communication and document sharing but doesn't provide the actual audit services directly.

Thoropass functions as both the compliance platform and the auditing firm, with AICPA peer-reviewed CPA credentials for SOC assessments, PCI QSAC certification, and HITRUST assessor accreditation. This eliminates the need to coordinate between separate vendors and ensures seamless integration between compliance preparation and audit execution.

Multi-framework Support

Scrut supports 60+ compliance frameworks including SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, PCI DSS, and GDPR with comprehensive control mapping and multi-entity management capabilities. The platform emphasizes breadth across various compliance requirements with strong GRC integration.

Thoropass handles multiple frameworks including SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, PCI DSS, and HITRUST through a unified platform with continuous framework additions. The platform focuses on streamlined multi-framework audits executed by the same team, reducing complexity and coordination overhead.

Automated Evidence Collection

Scrut provides continuous control monitoring with automated evidence gathering across 80+ integrations spanning cloud providers, identity management, and business applications. The platform emphasizes real-time compliance tracking with comprehensive dashboard visibility.

Thoropass offers automated evidence collection through 200+ auditor-vetted integrations, with AI-powered evidence review capabilities that validate collected data before audit review. This approach aims to reduce manual evidence preparation and improve audit efficiency.

Risk Management

Scrut includes comprehensive risk management capabilities as part of its broader GRC platform, with dedicated modules for risk assessment, tracking, and mitigation across the organization. This provides integrated risk oversight alongside compliance activities.

Thoropass incorporates risk management features within its compliance automation platform, though the primary focus remains on audit readiness and execution rather than standalone GRC functionality. Risk tracking supports the overall compliance posture assessment.

Vendor Management

Scrut provides dedicated vendor management capabilities, allowing organizations to assess and monitor third-party risk as part of their overall GRC strategy. This includes vendor assessments, contract tracking, and ongoing risk monitoring.

Thoropass does not offer standalone vendor management features, focusing instead on direct compliance and audit execution. Organizations requiring comprehensive vendor risk management would need additional tools or services.

Trust Center

Scrut offers Trust Vault as a marketed product feature, providing a live, gated trust page with automated security questionnaire capabilities to streamline customer due diligence processes. This helps reduce sales friction by providing self-service compliance information.

Thoropass includes a Trust Center feature that was in beta as of recent updates, offering similar capabilities for sharing compliance status and documentation with customers and prospects. The feature aims to automate security questionnaire responses and provide transparency.

Penetration Testing

Scrut does not provide penetration testing services directly, requiring organizations to work with third-party providers for these security assessments. The platform can track and manage pen test results but doesn't conduct the testing.

Thoropass includes in-house penetration testing services as part of its comprehensive security assessment offering, reducing the need for additional vendors and ensuring integrated reporting with compliance audits. This consolidates security testing with audit activities.

PCI ASV Scanning

Scrut does not offer PCI Approved Scanning Vendor services, requiring organizations to engage separate ASV providers for PCI DSS compliance requirements. The platform can track scan results but doesn't perform the scanning function.

Thoropass provides PCI ASV scanning services as of May 2025, offering external vulnerability scanning required for PCI DSS compliance alongside their audit and compliance services. This reduces vendor management overhead for PCI-regulated organizations.

AI Evidence Review

Scrut focuses on automated evidence collection and dashboard presentation but does not emphasize AI-powered review capabilities for validating collected evidence. The platform relies on traditional automated monitoring and human review processes.

Thoropass incorporates AI-native technology including First Pass AI for evidence review and validation, helping identify potential issues before formal audit review. This aims to reduce audit loops and improve evidence quality throughout the process.

100+ Integrations

Scrut offers 80+ integrations across cloud, identity, HRIS, and other business systems, providing solid coverage for most organizational tech stacks. While comprehensive, the integration catalog is smaller than some competitors in the space.

Thoropass provides 200+ auditor-vetted integrations spanning cloud providers, business applications, development tools, and security platforms. Thoropass has a significantly lower price tag because of the consolidation of audit and compliance into one platform. Although pricing does vary for each organization, initial scoping is representative of the true price tag. With traditional auditors and other compliance platforms, the price you get is only one side of the full price, since you'll need the other to complement its service.

Conclusion

Scrut works well for organizations seeking a comprehensive GRC platform with strong vendor and risk management capabilities, particularly those who prefer to work with their existing audit firm or want flexibility in auditor selection. The platform's Trust Vault and multi-entity management features make it suitable for complex organizational structures requiring broad compliance oversight.

Thoropass is ideal for organizations wanting to consolidate their compliance and audit functions with a single vendor, especially those prioritizing speed and simplicity in their audit cycles. The all-in-one approach with built-in penetration testing and PCI ASV scanning appeals to teams looking to reduce vendor management overhead while maintaining rigorous audit standards through their accredited audit services.